When Markets Fall: A Steady Approach to Volatility
A drop in the market is not a sign that something broke. It is the price of admission for long-term growth. What matters is not the fall itself, but what you do when it happens.
If you are invested for the long term and the headlines have you uneasy, wondering whether you should sell, move to cash, or just stop looking, this is written for you. The short version: the moment it feels urgent to act is usually the moment to act least. Here is why, and what we actually do instead.
Winter is not a surprise
I have spent my whole career studying how markets behave when they fall apart, and I have sat beside clients through more than one real downturn in the last two decades. The specific causes are always different. The pattern rarely is.
I think about it the way I think about the seasons. For every winter, a summer has always followed. I cannot tell you the date it arrives, and I would never promise you one, but I have never seen a winter that lasted forever. Markets work in cycles the way nature does. They cannot go straight up, no matter how much we would like them to. They need time to digest, to catch their breath, to shake out the excess before they climb again. A pullback is not the machine breaking. It is the machine working the way it always has.
History is full of hard stretches. The crash of 1987. The dot-com peak at the end of the 1990s and the long, grinding decade that followed, where the market went almost nowhere for ten years. The downturns of the last twenty years that I walked through with real clients and real money on the line. If you only remember the recoveries, you forget how frightening each of those felt while you were inside it. I remember. And remembering is exactly what lets me stay steady when the next one comes, because I have seen this movie before and I know it is not the first act of a tragedy. It is winter.
The fall is not the risk. What you do about it is.
Here is the single most important idea in this entire guide. A market that drops has only cost you money on paper. A decline becomes a permanent, real loss at exactly one moment: when you sell into it.
This is the trap, and it is a cruel one, because everything in your body is screaming at you to do the one thing that turns a temporary dip into a permanent wound. The fear feels like information. It feels like action will protect you. In reality, selling when you are afraid locks in the loss and then hands you a second, even harder problem: you now have to be right twice. You have to know when to get out, and then you have to know when to get back in. Almost nobody gets both right, and the people who get out often sit in cash through the very recovery they were waiting for, watching from the sidelines as the summer they feared would never come arrives without them.
Doing nothing feels passive. In a storm, it is often the single most disciplined and profitable thing you can do.
Why we can stay calm: the plan already assumed this
People sometimes mistake calm for optimism, as if I am simply hoping it all works out. It is the opposite of hope. It is preparation.
Before a downturn ever arrives, we stress test your financial plan against one. We deliberately assume that tough times will come, that markets will fall, that there will be stretches that test your nerve, and we build your plan to stay intact through them anyway. We do not design a plan that only works if the weather stays nice. We design one built to withstand the weather we know is coming, because some version of it always does. When the storm finally hits, we are not scrambling to react. We are watching a scenario we already planned for play out.
That is the difference between calm that is earned and calm that is wishful. When I tell a client their retirement is still on track in the middle of a scary market, I am not soothing them. I am reading back to them a plan we built, on purpose, to survive this exact moment.
How the portfolio is built to weather it
The plan is one layer. What is inside the portfolio is the other, and it is built on the same philosophy.
We use high-quality, diversified investments rather than chasing whatever is hot at the moment. The thrilling stock everyone is talking about is usually the one that falls hardest and recovers least when the tide goes out. Diversification is unglamorous by design. It means you never have everything riding on a single bet, which is precisely what you want when a storm rolls through and finds the weak spots.
I also spend a great deal of my time on something most people never think to ask about: risk-adjusted returns. It is not enough to ask what an investment earned. The real question is how much risk you had to take to earn it. Two portfolios can post the same return while one of them put you through white-knuckle swings to get there and the other got you to the same place far more smoothly. Earning a good return is only half the job. Earning it without taking more risk than you needed to is the other half, and it is the half that lets you sleep at night when the headlines turn ugly.
The one risk that may not recover: too much in a single stock
Everything I have said so far about staying put and riding out the storm assumes a diversified portfolio. There is one situation where staying put is the danger rather than the safety, and I have watched it play out first-hand more than once in my career, so I want to be direct about it.
It is having a large share of your net worth tied up in a single company's stock. It goes wrong in two ways. Sometimes the whole market falls and the concentrated position falls with it, except there is no diversification underneath to cushion the blow. Other times it is worse and stranger: something happens to that one company specifically, a bad quarter, a failed product, a scandal, a lawsuit, and the stock drops hard even while the rest of the market is perfectly calm. You can do everything right and still get hit by a risk that belonged to one company alone.
Here is the distinction that matters most, and it is the reason this risk deserves its own section. The market as a whole has always, eventually, recovered. A single company carries no such guarantee. Names that were household words, that everyone assumed were permanent, have fallen and never come back. A diversified portfolio can wait out a winter. A single stock can have a winter that does not end.
This is especially real for the people I work with most closely: executives who have accumulated years of their own company's stock through equity compensation, and business owners whose wealth is concentrated in the company they built. The loyalty is understandable, and the tax and timing considerations are real, so this is rarely about selling everything at once. But the risk is just as real as the loyalty, and it deserves a deliberate plan to manage it down over time, before an event no one can predict makes the decision for you. Concentration may be what built your wealth. It does not have to be what takes it.
When markets fall, we look for the opening
Here is the part that surprises people. A down market is not only something to endure. Handled well, it is a window to act in your favor, and some of the most valuable moves we make happen precisely when things look worst.
When prices are down, we look for ways to turn the decline into an advantage. We can harvest losses, often through direct indexing, capturing a tax benefit from a paper decline without abandoning your position in the market. We can convert retirement dollars to a Roth while values are depressed, so the recovery happens inside a tax-free account rather than a taxable one, which pairs directly with the gap-year planning I have written about separately. We can put idle cash to work in areas where we hold long-term conviction, buying quality at better prices than we could a few months earlier. Custom structured notes can also have a role for the right client in the right situation.
None of this is about predicting the bottom, which no one can do. It is about being ready to act with intention while everyone else is frozen. The disciplined investor does not just survive the winter. They plant in it.
When a down market should actually prompt a call
I want to be clear that steadiness is not the same as burying your head. There is a right time to pick up the phone, and knowing the difference matters.
The wrong reason to call is that the market moved. The market moving is not news, it is the market doing its job, and it is already accounted for in your plan. The right reason to call is that your life moved. If your situation has changed, if you have a large cash need on the horizon, if you are close to the point of drawing on your portfolio, or if something has shifted in your circumstances, those are real planning events worth a conversation. We react to changes in your life, not to changes in the headlines. One deserves a response. The other deserves patience.
There is one more reason to call that I want to name directly, because I have watched it play out for years. Often the thing that pushes someone toward a panicked decision is not the market at all. It is a conversation. A friend, a cousin, a neighbor who follows the market closely and means well, but who is reacting to the very same frightening headlines as everyone else and does not know the first thing about your actual plan. That fear is contagious, and it can undo months of discipline over a single dinner. If someone in your life has you rattled, that is not a reason to act. It is a reason to call the person who actually knows your numbers, before you do anything at all. We would far rather take that call than help clean up after a decision made in a moment of borrowed panic.
And this goes a step further. If someone you care about is the one who is frightened, whether or not they are a client of ours, we are glad to be a steady voice for them too. If you know someone who could use a calm, straight conversation during a scary stretch, send them our way. For any reason, and for the people who matter to you, we are here to help.
Common questions when markets get rocky
Should I sell when the market drops? For a long-term investor, selling into a decline is usually the one move most likely to cause lasting harm, because it turns a temporary paper loss into a permanent realized one and then requires you to time your way back in. A falling market is generally a reason to revisit your plan, not your resolve. If your plan was built well, it already anticipated this.
Should I move everything to cash and wait for things to calm down? This feels safe and often is not. Markets have historically done much of their recovering in short, unpredictable bursts, frequently before it feels safe to return, so sitting in cash risks missing the rebound you were waiting for. Past performance is never a guarantee, but the cost of being on the sidelines at the wrong moment is real.
Is this time different? Every downturn feels unique while you are inside it, and the specific cause always is. What tends not to change is the underlying pattern: markets fall, they test your nerve, and historically they have gone on to recover, though no one can promise the timing. "This time is different" is one of the most expensive phrases in investing.
Should I stop investing or pause my contributions during a downturn? Continuing to invest through a downturn means you are buying at lower prices, which is the opposite of the instinct most people feel. Stopping when things are cheap and resuming when they feel safe again is buying high and selling low in slow motion. For most long-term savers, steady contributions through the rough stretches are a feature, not a risk.
A friend or relative who follows the market is telling me to get out. Should I listen? Someone who follows the market is usually reacting to the same headlines as everyone else, and however much they care about you, they do not know the details of your plan, your timeline, or your goals. General market fear is not the same thing as advice built around your situation. Before acting on a conversation that rattled you, talk to the person who actually knows your numbers.
How do I know if my portfolio can actually handle a downturn? This is the right question, and it is best answered before the storm, not during it. A plan that has been stress tested against tough markets, and a portfolio built on quality and diversification rather than the latest hot bet, is what lets you ride out volatility without being forced to sell at the wrong time. If no one has ever walked you through how your plan holds up in a bad market, that is worth doing.
I have a large amount of my net worth in one stock. Should I be worried? A concentrated position in a single stock carries a risk a diversified portfolio does not. A company-specific event can permanently impair it, and unlike the market as a whole, an individual company is not guaranteed to recover. This does not automatically mean selling, and if the stock came from equity compensation there are real tax and timing factors to weigh, but it is worth a deliberate plan to manage that concentration over time rather than leaving it to chance.
The market is down. Is there anything I should actually be doing? Sometimes yes, but on offense rather than in panic. Down markets can open the door to tax-loss harvesting, Roth conversions at lower values, and putting cash to work at better prices. These are deliberate, planned moves, which is exactly why they are worth coordinating with your advisor rather than improvising alone.
Every winter, a summer
I will leave you where I started. I do not know when the next downturn will come, how deep it will go, or how long it will last, and anyone who claims they do is guessing. What I know is that it will come, because it always does, and that it will pass, because that always has too.
My job is not to promise you endless sunshine. It is to build you a plan sturdy enough to stand through the winter, to keep you from turning a season you can weather into a loss you cannot, and to find the openings that a hard market quietly creates. The investors who come through downturns well are almost never the ones who reacted fastest. They are the ones who were prepared before it started and steady while it lasted.
Winter comes. So does summer. We plan for both.
This guide is educational and general in nature and is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. All investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal, and no strategy assures success or protects against loss. Diversification does not guarantee a profit or protect against loss. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Any decisions should be made in the context of your own situation and in consultation with your financial and tax professionals.
Securities and Advisory services offered through LPL Financial, A Registered Investment Advisor, Member FINRA/SIPC
